Sugar dating, compared · 18+
Generous is fine. Too good to be true is a scam.
What each sugar dating site costs and who pays, what it actually verifies, what it does with your data, and what its users complain about. For sugar babies and sugar daddies alike. Every fact links its source, and we start with the scam that costs people the most.
What we compare, and how
What it costs (and who pays)
Subscription or credits, which side pays, auto-renewal and refund rules. None of these sites shows prices before sign-up, so we say whose figures we use and when they were checked.
Verification & safety
Selfie, ID, income or background checks: what's required, what's optional, and what the site's own terms admit it doesn't check.
Scams & regulators
Fake-profile and billing complaints, BBB and Trustpilot records, lawsuits and government action. The sugar daddy scam is the biggest risk on every one of these sites.
Privacy record
Whether the privacy policy says it sells or shares your data, how long it keeps it, and any reported breaches.
Who's on it
Minimum age, markets, how the site describes itself, and member counts, which are always the company's own unverified claims.
Five sugar dating sites, side by side
Listed from the biggest name to the most niche. The order is not a ranking. We have no affiliate deal with any of these sites, so the links are plain links and nobody paid for a position. Two things are true of all five: none publishes prices before you sign up, and none runs mandatory background checks. Read how the sugar daddy scam works before you join any of them.
Affiliate disclosure: some links to the platforms on SugarBaby.now may earn us a commission if you sign up or pay. It never costs you more, and no platform pays to be listed or to change what we write. How we rate
| Platform | Best for | What it costs (and who pays) | Verification & safety | Privacy record | Scams & regulators | Links |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SeekingSugar dating site, now sold as "luxury dating" (formerly SeekingArrangement) | The biggest pool of members and the most verification, from the site that started the category. | Free to join; paid tiers, prices not published | Selfie check for new users; ID optional | Says it doesn't sell data; ad targeting | BBB: not rated, 47 complaints | |
| SugarDaddyMeetSugar dating site, subscription | The cheapest subscription we found, and a short refund window if you change your mind. | ~$50/mo; both sides pay to message | Selfie badge; no background checks | May "sell" data to ad networks | Trustpilot 1.5/5; a federal case | |
| Secret BenefitsSugar dating site, pay-per-credit | Sugar daddies who'd rather buy credits than commit to a subscription, in the US, Canada, the UK, Australia or Ireland. | Credits, no subscription; ~$59 per 100 | Profile review; video check optional | Ad targeting; no retention limit | Trustpilot 1.6/5 (981 reviews) | |
| WhatsYourPrice"Pay for a first date" bidding site | People who like everything upfront: one side offers a sum for a first date, the other accepts or counters. | Credits ~$50/100 + the date offer | Free selfie badge; $4.99 ID check | Says it doesn't sell; ad opt-out | Trustpilot 1.7/5; BBB not rated | |
| SugarbookSugar dating app and site | Students and members in Asia, especially Malaysia and Singapore, where it started. | Sugar daddies pay; ~$90/mo | Face check claimed; terms disclaim | 2021 policy; no deletion timeline | Blocked in Malaysia; founder arrested (2021) |
Facts last checked November 2026. Each platform's review page lists the sources.
Before you join one
$929M lost to romance and confidence fraud reported to the FBI in 2025, across 23,159 complaints. Sugar daddy scams are counted in that category.
Weeks is how long the FTC says a bank can take to discover a fake check, and the person who deposited it repays the money.
46 months in federal custody for a lawyer who paid a woman he met on a sugar daddy site to fly to Las Vegas for sex.
Sources: FBI IC3, 2025 Internet Crime Report, FTC, fake check scams, US Attorney, S.D. Cal.. Read our safety guide and where the legal line is.